I used this product faithfully until the tube was completely gone. Nothing changed with my skin. I was anxious to use this product, however, was disappointed. Other products I have used with Retinol, there was tingling and slight redness, which proved the product actually contained Retinol - Neither of these occurred with this product. It was just a moisturizer. Now I see new products from Origins with Retinoid, and I am hesitant to try them. Originally posted on www.origins.co.uk